Tuesday, February 13, 2007

Trading with the Sea

Trading with the Sea

Frederic Bastiat sums up my feelings towards the trade deficit. He tells a story about himself and the protectionist Mauguin:

I was at Bordeaux. I had a cask of wine which was worth 50 francs; I sent it to Liverpool, and the customhouse noted on its records an export of 50 francs.

At Liverpool the wine was sold for 70 francs. My representative converted the 70 francs into coal, which was found to be worth 90 francs on the market at Bordeaux. The customhouse hastened to record an import of 90 francs.

Balance of trade, or the excess of imports over exports: 40 francs.

These 40 francs, I have always believed, putting my trust in my books, I had gained. But M. Mauguin tells me that I have lost them, and that France has lost them in my person.
Bastiat earned 40 francs in profit, but according to the government bookkeepers France was in deficit, which was bad. Bastiat follows with a second story:

I had had some truffles shipped from PĂ©rigord which cost me 100 francs; they were destined for two distinguished English cabinet ministers for a very high price, which I proposed to turn into pounds sterling. Alas, I would have done better to eat them myself (I mean the truffles, not the English pounds or the Tories). All would not have been lost, as they were, for the ship that carried them off sank on its departure. The customs officer, who had noted on this occasion an export of 100 francs, never had any re-import to enter in this case.

Hence, M. Mauguin would say, France gained 100 francs; for it was, in fact, by this sum that the export, thanks to the shipwreck, exceeded the import. If the affair had turned out otherwise, if I had received 200 or 300 francs' worth of English pounds, then the balance of trade would have been unfavorable, and France would have been the loser.
And thus in terms of the trade deficit, there are some who would feel it better to trade with the sea than to trade with others and get something in return.

1 comment:

Jenny said...

I like your last line there. I never thought of complaints about the trade deficit in that way. Why would people be for trading and not getting anything back in return? Put that way, it sounds ridiculous.